Sickafus Sheepskins & Shearlings Reviews – Current

Our product reviews from around the world.

4/03/2024 Reviewed by:
Anne Baker
Doylestown, PA

I could not be happier or more in love with this coat!! You did a beautiful job and I will be recommending you to anyone who will listen. My daughters approve too! Thanks again, so much!

3/30/2024 Reviewed by:
Boyce, VA

I bought my coat from you a few years ago and its still making me look good! Thank you!

3/21/2024 Reviewed by:

I wanted to thank you for the beautiful vests and hats that I purchased from you in March. You were such a pleasure to deal with and it was impressive how quickly my custom items arrived at my door. Your personal touch was refreshing.

2/02/2024 Reviewed by:
Karen Brown

We got the coats today. We love them! Thank you so much!

5/08/2023 Reviewed by:
Jane B.
Buckingham, PA

Lisa Women's Shearling Sheepskin Coat 3/4 Length
“My Lisa coat arrived today. It’s gorgeous, and fits perfectly! You scored a home run with this one. My husband was so impressed with the quality he ordered a new pair of slippers.”

5/02/2023 Reviewed by:
John Mogab

Karl Men’s Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“The coat I ordered recently arrived today , earlier than I had expected , and I wanted to take a minute to let you know that it is as nice as advertised! The fit is very good, the skins nice, tailoring well done and length just what I wanted. I will spray it with the protectant you recommended later this week and put it away till we start getting cold weather again in the fall. I will look forward to wearing it next winter. (After 40 years in Colorado, I am pretty tired of down jackets for half the year every year!)

Thanks for the ease and accuracy of the measuring and ordering process, and the quality of the final product, at a very fair price.”

1/29/2023 Reviewed by:
Jim Reid
Fishers, IN

Kelvin Men's Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“Perfect fit. Love the coat! Thank you.”

12/16/2022 Reviewed by:
Dennis Martin
Twinsburg, OH

Steve Men's Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“Wow! Received my coat this morning. Love it. Just in time for next week’s cold weather. Thank you for your patience with me and your immediate responses to all my emails. I was impressed by the time in which it was made, size accuracy and quality. I would recommend you and your establishment anytime. One very satisfied customer.”

12/13/2022 Reviewed by:

Women's WWII B3 Aviator Shearling Sheepskin Bomber Jacket / Coat
“Just received the bomber jacket – it fits great!”

11/03/2022 Reviewed by:
Ash Fork, AZ

“One of your wonderful coats is keeping a very happy customer warm at The Grand Canyon on a chilly November morning.”

10/28/2022 Reviewed by:
Chicago, IL

“Coat arrived yesterday. It is great.”

1/14/2022 Reviewed by:

“Pat I love my genuine sheepskin coat, good job, great fit.”

1/03/2022 Reviewed by:
Donna Allen
Charlotte, NC

“You and your fantastic team did a beautiful job on the coat for my fiance. It is top notch quality and he could not be happier.”

12/18/2021 Reviewed by:
Aaron Gustavus
Baytown, Texas

Kelvin Men's Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“I love my Kelvin sheepskin coat. It’s perfect keeps the wind out and the heat in.”

10/12/2021 Reviewed by:
W. Patrick Kelley, Sr.
Sonora, California

Lisa Women's Black Shearling Sheepskin Coat 3/4 Length
“One of the nicest leather coats I’ve ever seen. Great work.”

8/27/2021 Reviewed by:
Robert Cooke
New South Wales, Australia

Kelvin Men’s Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“G’day Pat. Just wanted you to know my coat arrived today and it fits like a glove. We have had some warm days lately but the last couple have been quite cold with more forecast so I might get to wear it in public yet. So, in case you haven’t guessed I’m pretty pleased. Well done and thanks.”

8/03/2021 Reviewed by:
Jessica Kokoszka

Women's Skuffies Slippers
“These slippers are so comfy!! I’ve been wearing L.L. Bean’s wicked good clogs for 20 years but they have lately declined in quality. I was looking for something to replace those. I ordered online and they shipped out right away; I received them the day after they shipped. Awesome.

I love how warm they are without making my feet sweat. I typically wear a 5 or 5.5 depending on brand, so I ordered the small (5-6). They actually just fit, my heel is aligned with the back. They maybe stretch and as the sheepskin gets compacted over time will be a little roomier, but I think anyone on the upper size of the range might want to size up.”

7/22/2021 Reviewed by:
Ocean View, DE

Coyote Pelt
“I received the package with the coyote pelt in it today… I am thrilled and pleased beyond words for the beautiful pelt you sent me for my grandsons birthday. Thank you for going above and beyond the call of duty for how beautifully you even cut it for him! I will highly recommend your shop and your website whenever I get a chance!”

6/09/2021 Reviewed by:
Donna Barnard
Victoria, Australia

Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“Thank you Pat for my beautiful coat. It will keep me very warm down here on the southern coast of Australia where we get blasts straight off the Antarctic! And also for the CD which is on high rotation at home. Thanks to you and your team for a quality made item and great customer service. I was kept informed every step of the way and my coat arrived promptly and beautifully packaged. I will happily recommend you to my friends.”

4/24/2021 Reviewed by:
Madison, AL

Women’s Sheepskin Shearling Snuggies Slippers
“It has been delivered. My daughter loves the slippers.”

4/15/2021 Reviewed by:

Joseph Stroller Length 40″ Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“Pat coat arrived. Lovely skins!! Quite comfortable. Thanks for your prompt attention.”

3/22/2021 Reviewed by:

“The new boots fit like a glove and the gloves fit like comfortable boots. Thank you also for offering USA made items.”

1/26/2021 Reviewed by:

Martinez Hand Rolled Cigars
“I bought these for my father-in-law last year when we stopped for clothing items. He loved them..said numerous times it’s the best he ever had. I just ordered more! Stop and visit yourself if able, excellent selection of items with great people ready to help you.”

12/29/2020 Reviewed by:
McDonough, GA

Lisa Women's Shearling Sheepskin Coat & Men's WWII B3 Aviator Shearling Sheepskin Bomber Jacket / Coat
“You give the gift of warmth when the days are bitter cold.
I honestly don’t shiver anymore when I wear your Lisa coat that you all made so many years ago. I can’t thank you enough. I feel like I am embraced in a warm hug!! We all need that more than ever. What a gift you all give to the world. ?
PS. My husband still loves his brown Bomber! Wears it from November to March every year. Still looks like new.”

11/24/2020 Reviewed by:
Kim Goerg
Rhinelander, WI

Men's Country Marlboro Genuine Sheepskin Coat
“Coat just arrived a few minutes ago. I had to let you know that it fit perfectly even with a light wool vest underneath. The quality of the sheepskins were excellent. True craftsmanship on the cutting and sewing of the skins.”

10/28/2020 Reviewed by:
Christina Holloman
Middletown, PA

Tibetan Lamb Sheepskin Boots – Style# 1294w
“Excellent quality product!! Tibetan lamb sheepskin and fur is super soft and very comfortable! Perfect fit, size correctly size 8 women.”

10/24/2020 Reviewed by:
Kansas City, MO

Men's Cowboy Will Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“The quality, styling, craftsmanship, and order processing is A+++. We posted a 5 star Google review with comments as these reviews helped me feel comfortable ordering online. Thank you so much. You are so gifted and we are so grateful!”

07/40/2020 Reviewed by:
Jay Glass

Genuine Sheepskin Motorcycle Butt Savers LW
“I stopped in today, 4th of July 2020. I have known of Pat Garrett’s Sheepskins for along time, but finally made a purchase. I bought a black sheepskin for my Harley’s saddle and then rode about 70 miles. Awesome improvement on comfort, and got a few compliments on it at dealership.

Thank you for having the best quality and style for exactly what I was looking for. Keep up the good work, and I didn’t catch their names but staff was excellent.”

02/16/2020 Reviewed by:
William Markel
Monroeville PA, USA

Kelvin Men’s Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“Pat..Just received my coat, and it fits perfectly. Looks great and feels even better. Thanks much. Will remember your store and your products.”

02/05/2020 Reviewed by:

Men's Skuffies Slippers
“I just wanted to take a moment and reach out to say THANK YOU for having such a great product and providing excellent customer service!

In December I ordered a pair of the “Scuffies” slippers for my husband. When they arrived they were beautiful and seemed well made, but were just too big for him. I called the store and spoke with Jeff, who assured me that we’d get the size corrected. It was an easy process to send back the original pair, and within no time a new pair arrived and fits perfectly!~ Thank you again and I can’t wait to get my pair!”

01/30/2020 Reviewed by:
Steven King’s Movie Production Company

Johnny Men's Full Length Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“PAT! The coats and hats are AMAZING!!!!!!!!! Everyone here LOVES them!

And… thank you SO SO much for my GORGEOUS gloves and your signed CD! I will listen to it in the car on my drive home and I will wear the gloves on set next week. Its been a pleasure getting to know you. Have a fantastic Friday.”

01/28/2020 Reviewed by:
Anthony Peart

Tibetan Lamb Jacket
“Mate, Tibetan lamb coat is great! Thank you.”

01/24/2020 Reviewed by:
John Raney
Dubois, Wyoming, USA

Lisa Women’s Shearling Sheepskin Coat 3/4 Length
“Pat…We got Sue’s coat and she loves it. Thank you for your help.”

01/24/2020 Reviewed by:
Karen Redwood
Cambridge, ON, Canada

Gracie – 3/4 Length Women’s Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“I got my coat, yesterday, it’s beautiful & fits perfectly.”

01/24/2020 Reviewed by:
Pat Freel

Karl Men's Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“I received the coat yesterday. It is magnificent!”

01/24/2020 Reviewed by:
Charlie Utz

Johnny Men's Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“I just received the larger coat. I am happy to report that it fits much better then the last one. Thank you for taking the time and making another coat. Thank you.”

01/14/2020 Reviewed by:
Rhonda Nagel
Cedar City, UT, USA

Womens Country Marlboro Shearling Sheepskin Coat
“I was away and returned over the weekend to find the package with the coat. I LOVE IT! Thank you so much for working with me to get me the perfect one!”